Parents file Open Meetings lawsuit against BVSD · September 30, 2026

A better plan starts with a transparent process.

Update · November 9, 2026

The parents appeal

On November 9, the parents filed a notice of appeal with the Colorado Court of Appeals, challenging the October 28 ruling that denied their request for a preliminary injunction. The underlying case remains pending in Boulder County District Court. We support the appeal.

The appeal raises the same question the parents put to the Colorado Supreme Court on November 3:

Can a public body discuss and develop public policy through a coordinated series of private meetings with one or two elected officials at a time, without considering whether those meetings, taken together, moved part of the policy-making process out of public view in violation of Colorado’s Open Meetings Law?

On November 4, the Supreme Court declined to take the question up directly. It turns down most petitions of this kind and gives no reasons. The Court of Appeals is the ordinary route for the question, and the parents have now taken it.

Appeals take time. First the court record goes to the Court of Appeals. Then each side files briefs, which is expected to run into the spring and may be followed by oral argument. We will post updates as the case develops.

On September 22, 2026, BVSD voted 5–2 to adopt the Resilient Schools plan, moving roughly 1,800 students for less than 1% in budget savings and a five-point gain in the utilization of Boulder's elementary school buildings.

On September 30, 2026, parents from the Douglass, Flatirons, and Mesa school communities filed a lawsuit under the Colorado Open Meetings Law. The suit alleges that key policy decisions behind the Resilient Schools plan were made without the public notice, observation, and participation the law requires. Those claims will be decided by the court.

On October 8, 2026, after a hearing on the parents’ motion, Judge Dea M. Lindsey stayed BVSD’s implementation of any plan regarding school closures until she ruled. On October 21, the parents asked the court to hold BVSD in contempt of that order: the four schools were left off the map of that evening’s BVSD is the Place to Be Showcase, the K–12 school finder no longer listed them, and the Flatirons website told families the school would close. The court has not ruled on that motion.

On October 28, the court declined to pause the plan while the case is decided, and the stay ended. The lawsuit goes on. The same day, BVSD responded to the complaint with a motion to dismiss it; the parents plan to oppose that motion, and their response is due November 18.

On November 3, the parents asked the Colorado Supreme Court to decide whether a series of private meetings between BVSD administrators and Board members should have been judged as a whole. On November 4, the Supreme Court declined to hear it. On November 9, the parents appealed the October 28 ruling to the Colorado Court of Appeals.

We support it, because decisions with lasting consequences for students have to be made in the open.

Transparency still matters. It is disappointing that the court didn’t pause the plan. Allowing the plan to move forward does damage that can’t be undone. It reassigns kids and divides communities. Even so, we will keep working to hold BVSD accountable and to make sure future decisions are made in the open. Please keep paying attention and keep caring, especially with school board elections coming up next year. We will report on the case here as it moves through the court.

What does this mean for 2027-28 enrollment?

Many families are wondering what happens if they make a choice-enrollment decision under the current plan and the court later overturns the plan. Unfortunately, there isn’t a clear answer yet. There are too many ways the litigation and the district’s implementation of the plan could unfold to predict what that would mean for any individual family.

For now, we have to take this one step at a time. The next steps in the Open Meetings case are the appeal and the parents’ response to the motion to dismiss. For families, the immediate task is making the enrollment decisions in front of us based on the information available now.

What it asks

That the court declare that the process behind the plan broke Colorado’s Open Meetings Law: that BVSD set key policy direction without the public notice the law requires, and that its September 22 approval rested on decisions made out of public view.

The parents recognize that families, teachers, staff and schools need certainty, but decisions with lasting consequences for students must be made openly. Colorado law requires it.

What it doesn't ask

The lawsuit does not ask the court to decide which schools stay open or what education policy BVSD should adopt.

It also does not seek to pause Open Enrollment, school tours or information sessions, so families should keep sharing their preferences and exploring all their options.

What happens if the court agrees

Relief could include setting aside BVSD's approval of the plan and requiring a properly noticed public process.

That would not dictate the outcome. After a lawful process, BVSD would remain free to make the decision it believes is right.

In the news

Axios Boulder · Oct 29

BVSD school closures move ahead

Mitchell Byars

Plaintiff Katie Rosenthal: “Unfortunately, the plan does damage that can’t be undone. It reassigns kids and divides communities.” The legal fight goes on.